Peanut butter cookie with peanut butter chips. Is there a thing as too much Peanut Butter…? We don’t think so! The Double Peanut Butter cookie will make you feel like you’ve left Earth and entered heaven. This nutty masterpiece will make you nuts (pun intended). After trying many peanut butter cookies, we realized that nothing goes better with peanut butter than more peanut butter. A soft cookie with a crispy outside that will transport you to middle school recess!